• Philosophy – Is a Deistic conception of the Necessary Being coherent?

    The rise of Deism in Turkey – Is a Deistic conception of the Necessary Being coherent? A reply to Deism When I landed in the southern city of Adana in Turkey, my cousin picked me up and we started discussing the condition of the people, which then switched to the topics of religion & philosophy.

    Read more →

  • Theology/Jurisprudence

    Is Islamic Law arbitrary, random or are the Divine laws decreed with purpose of Maslaha (greater well-being)? Views of the Ash’arites, Mu’tazila & al-Razi Fakhr al-Din al-Razi mentions, “Our companions (the Ash’arites) maintain that God, Glorious and Exalted is He, performs no action with an objective (li gharar), for if this were the case, it

    Read more →

  • Was Husayn b. Ali thoughtless & hasty? A reply to Dr Israfil Balci of Turkey Dr Israfil Balci, a known academic in Turkey said, “As much as Yazid & Ibn Ziyad were tyrannical & oppressive, Husayn was equally hasty & thoughtless. His relatives & friends begged him not to go. Not only did he fall

    Read more →

  • Do the people really think that Husayn b. Ali started the tradition of revolt & uprising against tyranny? By God, Husayn only continued the Divine command of establishing the Divine will & decree that started with Adam up until the last messenger Muhammad b. Abdullah (a.s.). The stance of uprising is the path of the

    Read more →

  • Why did Huseyn b. Ali revolt against the system of the time? Do you believe Huseyn b. Ali revolted for the sake of power and authority? Did you really think that Huseyn rose, so the people pray and do ablution in a particular way?! Far from it! The stand of Huseyn was the stand of

    Read more →

  • Philosophy/Ethics/Jurisprudence – What is the purpose of Divine law & why do we obey God?

    To summarise the purpose of religion and Divine law (Shari’a) is the “improvement (salah) on earth, happiness (falah) in the afterlife” (Mehmet Erdogan). Divine law establishes the needs of the fitrah (the innate disposition) of the creation of God (the human being). The Divine law (Shari’a) is considerate, coherent, detailed, dynamic and it is satisfactory

    Read more →

  • Jurisprudence/Methodology – A Comparison between the Usuli & Traditionist methods

    Different methods of Islamic Law: A comparison between the Usuli and Traditionist methods When properly understanding Islamic Law (Shari’a), it is necessary to completely examine all the texts collectively. It is especially important to examine the texts chronologically & it is even more important to examine the clear commands & injunctions of the Qur’an and

    Read more →

  • Theology/Ethics/Sociology – The impact of Zaydi and Mu’tazilite theology on society

    Reminder: Theology/Philosophical paradigms will always impact legal theory, fiqh, sociology and the situation of the community The Mu’tazila, Ahl al-Adl (the people of justice) and the Zaydis highlighted the important position of Divine justice and wisdom when it comes to theology and practice. Hence why historically, the Zaydis and the Mu’tazilis (Ahl al-Adl) continuously upheld

    Read more →

  • History/Theology – Has Alī b. Abī Ṭālib used Ghadīr Khumm as a proof for his Imamate?

    The importance of Ghadīr Khumm for ‘Alī is highlighted by ‘Alī himself on the Day of Raḥba because he was demanding the Muslims to testify for the validity of the Sermon of Ghadīr. (Musnad Ahmad b. Hanbal) It is important to remember that ‘Alī could have simply mentioned the famous sermon by himself without asking

    Read more →

  • Philosophy/Theology – Why do we need revelation when we have reason?

    Philosophy – Why do we need Divine Revelation when we have reason? Imamzaydinstitute.org The Qur’an clearly opposes arrogance and reminds humanity that the cause of every beauty is actually from the Ultimate Creator. This includes intellect, knowledge, wisdom and morality. The Qur’an refutes the false conception of self-sufficiency by saying “he sees himself self-sufficient,” while

    Read more →